I just happen to have that whole entire button but I also have a black console that I bought off someone on here a month or so back and it came with the lid and all but the button was missing or broke off too. The spring part of the console door also doesn't have any spring action to it. My current grey one is doing fine at the moment but as the years pass by, the more brittle they get.
Sometimes those lids are on ebay. You can also fix your lid to not have any spring action and it is heavy enough to stay down. That's the way the black console is and the lid is in near perfect condition but it is missing the button and I have had one in my dresser drawer for the past 3 or so years, just sitting there. In other words, I'd hate to let it go because I know it is going to be a hard find, if something were to happen to the grey one that I'm using now or if I ever decided to go all out black on my interior.
Here are some names to check with.
1. Markviiiedrea
2. chargerxr
3. 98lincmk7lsc
Never know what either one of these might have.