True in that we do have it better than most of the world. However that doesn't mean we should just be complacent and say 'well it could be worse'. With just a bit of tweaking in our wealth distribution thinks could be so much better.
Let me ask this. Why do we have minimum wage laws? Shouldn't competition and the free market and all that stuff determine how much everybody makes? Couldn't it be that maybe we need some government oversight and regulations because the wealthy can't be trusted to reliably do the right thing?
Btw just today there's a new headline out that 1/6 of our country lives in poverty. Go trickle down economics! InB4 responses about how the poor have food, a car and a house with air conditioning so all is peachy
You have a monolithic view of the rich.
A big part of the problem is that the US has a 35% corporate tax rate the highest in the world to pay for our Great Society and a 14% Social Security tax up to 104k capped income and 3.5% Medicare tax with no cap on wages while Canada for instance has a 21% corporate rate.
The world wants business and offers what it has.
The high rate encourages companies to move production and profits out of country.
Profits that are made outside the country but not brought into the US are taxed only at the country of origin.
The rest of the world is competing for the wealth more now offering what is known in economics as comparative advantage in the form of cheaper labor and less regulation.
Those of us in the top 1% with S Corps taxed at personal rates once like contractors and domestic manufacturers,
doctors and other professionals who don't have the luxury of capital gains or foreign investment are the ones who carry the country and have to pay the top 35% rate along with their state taxes 9% in NY for instance.
That's a combined rate of 44%.
With a repeal of the Bush tax cuts it would be 49%.
Add in the SS and uncapped Medicare and it's over 50%
It's multinationals and those who use money to make money in capital gains on investments held for longer than 1 year that get the plumb 15% federal rate with their state tax on top of that.
I've finally started moving money that way.
However there have been some estimates that bringing everyone up to Warren Buffet's liking like to what the S Corps pay, his hypocritical tax appeals and unpayments notwithstanding,
would pay for 1 week of federal spending or 2%.
I suppose if we tried to repatriate the US Corps foreign profits with a low rate amnesty which has been tried before we might get another 2%.
4% more in the US social economy is big numbers but it disappointingly puts only a small 2 week dent into the underlying issue of people essentially outliving their usefulness by 15+ years instead of 5-7 when these programs were set up and accounted for.
Now that business has learned to do more with less workers that is not going to change.
Companies plan strategies to make money not jobs.
Machines are designed and created to minimize manual labor so production can be increased or even achieved while menial jobs are eliminated.
Some of the pie is shared with key workers who are paid hefty bonuses at Christmas.
This is how we have improved our efficiencies and strengthened our balance sheet.
Every worker is taxed and has to be insured whereas capital machines do need care and maintanence and a source of power but are not subject to human resources problems and issues and encumberances or taxed on a time or output basis and never will be.
Ohio eliminated it's property tax on heavy equipment a few years ago to compete better.
Even with the 1/6th poverty rate you point to hasn't put a dent into our ability to borrow money from the rest of the world seemingly indefinately.
The world is enabling our Moral Hazard of theft of the future which can only work in a constantly expanding and growing economy, unlikely with our aging costly underfunded retirees 8000 a day turning 65.
We'll spend it on Military Welfare make work projects and those "worthy" dependants but not the general lower and fallen middle class population.
Let him die was cheered by some members of the audience at the republican debate on monday.
Now there's constant talk of a Euro caused economic meldown if we and Germany don't bail out the socialist paradise of the rest of Europe that has leisurely dug itself into an even bigger hole than we are in.
It will be very hard to get higher tax rates out of the rich.