Just because a speaker is built different, doesn't mean it can't reproduce the same frequencies.
actually it kinda does... while in theory, it may be possible for two different styles (and different sized drivers) to be able to sound similar, in the real world, it just doesn't happen. even the smallest differences has an effect over sound quality. there are hundreds of different speakers out there, every one of them sounds different.
You're just saying the same thing I said earlier about surface area. C'mon, you're running in circles.
no, running in circles is simultaneously making an argument that two different speakers sound the same, but yet also sound different enough as to be worth spending money (especially for somebody that is supposed to be "not wanting to spend money...") to get better sound. which is it bud? can't bet on both horses.
Based on that I have ACTUALLY connected the components to an after market amp and they wouldn't hold up. These components are for looks and to make you feel better about the extra money you paid for the "premium sound".
maybe you should work on your tuning, just by listening to what you've said so far, you have no clue how to properly set stuff up without the knowledge of how things work... the OEM components can handle an amp no problem, I have personally installed amps on three different LS's while keeping the factory components. two 5ch and one with a dedicated 4ch for internals. never had a problem with being able to crank the hell out of them. only one of them ended up wanting to take it further and replace all the speakers. the other two were happy with how they sounded
Sounds like you haven't actually tried anything.
yeah, you're probably right, but then my company has probably been overpaying my since I have been getting paid to install sound systems for the last decade and a half, and running it for the last half of that. in 14 years I have never tried to experiment with anything.
See, you're just going off specs and specs don't mean nothing if you haven't put things to the test to see the REAL results.
see above, also since you haven't been around awhile, go ahead and search around. any of the people that I've help on here will be more than happy to tell you about REAL results.
Which I have done with both factory sets of speakers. So whatever you say of how a speaker is built or how it's 'supposed to perform', goes out the window when my test proved the opposite.
your one test, with your (questionable) ears, in your limited circumstances for some reason doesn't shake the year of experience I've personally seen... go figure.
All Janobala wants is to add a little more bass to his sound and I just suggested the cheap speakers just in case he had the factory components and isn't interested in spending money.
which he isnt going to get any more bass, thats what your not getting... he has the premium sound system. he has factory subs that are bigger and have much more power that the radio can dish out... your junk ass speakers could literally produce ten times as much bass and you still would be able to tell any difference over the subs... moreover, even with all that, it is not enough bass for him... do you really think that switching those speakers out is going to give him enough to satisfy his thirst?
With that, for some reason, you got offended when I said that those speakers outperformed the components. Seems like you're just trying to +1 because your'e the type of person that could never be wrong.
sorry I just get offended when somebody is seeking advice or help and there is that one person coming out of left field is spouting off just plain wrong information and conspiracies about premium sound option being a fake waste of money with no difference...
You also seem like the type that gets mad because you build something for $1000 and someone else comes and does better than you with a $100. I mean I wouldn't say that my V6 is faster then your v8 if it wasn't, because I could already hear you saying that it's not possible because the v8 puts out more HP right?. Cheers.
well I've sure seen my fair share of cobbled together sound systems, and even with how amazing they sounded, I still chose to spend ten fold what they did, just to get worse sound (if that was the case, I probably would have much of a customer base left coming back). yep, you got me there!
I wouldn't say that my V6 is faster then your v8 if it wasn't, because I could already hear you saying that it's not possible because the v8 puts out more HP right?. [/QUOTE] actually I thrive off of real world results. if you said that in front of me, I would just respond with "I'll be your huckleberry" and then we would find out right there instead of theorizing all night... I also know that just because its a V6 doesn't mean that it is slower than my V8, I also know very well what a V6 would have to have done to it to keep up. I also drive an LS, I am very aware that it doesn't win every race...