You achive the maximum efficient balance point where the tradeoff between horsepower and gas is at its best.
Here is where I see a flaw in your thinking in two areas...
1:The engine is turning at a higher RPM, so even though less fuel is being shot into the cylinders, per revolution, to create cumbustion and move the piston, the engine is running at a much higher RPM. More revolutions equal more gas. There would have to be a 50% drop in gas used per revolution to maintain the same gas mileage at 2000 RPM's as you would have at 1000 RPM's.
2: You don't need to make all the horsepower availible at that balance point to maintain highway speeds. driving at that higher RPM is wasting energy and gas. Look at how the vairable displacement engines work. The shut off cylinders at crusing speeds, reducing both fuel consumption and horsepower.
Your argument seems to be built around the idea that more horsepower equals better gas mileage. On the highway, under normal driving conditions, that is untrue.