being my first car, i don't have anything to compare it to rather than my other car which is a 2000 bmw 323ci. the bmw has been owned since new by my mom and is now at 140k miles. The only major thing to be replaced is the clutch which is expected in a manual after all those miles. I have an 03 which i just recently passed the 40k mile mark. I have the v6, which for a first car was a good buy but now that ive had it for a year i'm disappointed with the performance and i wish that i was a little bit faster and i also wished that it got better gas mileage. With my v6 and about a 70/30 highway to city driving im getting about 18 mpg on premium gas which starts to add up. I just test drove the new bmw 335i convertbile and i know that the cars are not really comparable one is luxury one is sporty, but the driving experience of the bmw blows the ls out of the water. so to answer your question of am i satisfied? I was for a while, but im not sick of the gas mileage, the crappy performance, and all the problems ive had with my car. I had the engine decarbonized, the tranny replaced at 36k, the front right and left tire rods replaced, the sunroof had to be resealed, the heated seat malfunctioned, the power seat didnt work, the driver seat has been replaced twice. Now i am the second owner of this car, so i dont know wht happened to it for the first 22k of its life, but it was an old woman that owned it so i'm pretty sure it wasnt abused. If i were to recommend a car i would say go bmw all the ay, in my opinion it lives up to the saying "the ultimate driivng machine." Now ill probably get rebuttles with the fact that you cant compare apples to oranges like comparing a 3 series to an ls, but IMO bmw all the way. I would compare it to a 5 series, but ive never driven 1.
oh and the performance may havbe been solved by getting a v8, but i didnt have the opportunity to get one.