Let's bump this again to see if there has been any progress on shocks for our cars.
Zombie thread. mmmm, postttsssss.
I'm doing some work on crossing over the s-type shocks, but don't have anything definitive. What I do know is:
- Same style upper mount, direct fit (use jag mount in an LS)
- Compressed length Jag shocks are about 1/8" longer
- Jag shocks have about an inch more travel (longer uncompressed)
- LS has a wider seat in the control arm, so you'd need to use thick washers/spacers or change the LCA
- Same style bumpers and seat for the shock itself (jag bumpers seems shorter in length)
What I haven't verified:
- Spring seat location on the shock and distance from the lower mount
- If the shock geometry is different due to the different LCA
- If the extended suspension range of motion from a longer uncompressed length causes sway-bar/LCA interference
- If the UCA is different to allow for an extended range of suspension travel (being the short arm and all)
Since the Jag shocks compressed length (assuming spring seat is in same position) is longer then the stock shock, this won't help anyone who is lowered and already bottoming out. If anything it would be marginally worse. A different shock might help prevent bottoming out depending upon the valving.
The only other things that worries me is that extra inch of travel on the Jag shocks. With my LS up in the air and the suspension fully unloaded, the sway bar is very close to the LCA. My concern is that allowing the suspension another potential 1" of swing might allow the sway bar to contact the LCA. This is why the LCA on the LS and Jag may be different, resulting in a different lower mounting eye. This slack could also be taken up in the geometry of the mounting, meaning that where the shock mounts in relation to the upper mount could be further towards the outside of the car. This means that you would have more shock travel in the same amount of suspension motion which in theory would allow a lesser spec shock to feel like it has more dampening.
To know for sure I will need to purchase a set of jag shocks and try mounting them on both sides (without springs) and seeing what kind of interference there might be in the suspensions range of motion. What I think (or hope) it is is a combination of both. I believe the curved S part of the LCA that goes for the forward bushing on the frame may be a little more aggressively curved to provide clearance. If the shock mount is also further out that would help the shock/spring do its job in terms of controlling vehicle momentum.
I'm sure that's not the "IT WERKS!" answer you want, but that's what I've found out.
Here's what I mean about the LCA and Sway Bar potentially hitting. They are only about a 1/4" apart right now at it's extremeties. Plus if you over-extend the UCA you could bend/break the arm or screw up the ball joint: