Wow this thread was Necro-threaded once by over a full year
I am bringing it back once more to discuss the original post. It's now been over 2 years since owning both the First Gen and the Second Gen. And my opinion has changed. I would like to refine my thoughts on the two cars, once more.
So what changed my views?
Well aside from reliability issues with my first gen, I got used to the second Gen. What gave me an illusion that the first gen handled better was simply the response. I still don't like electronic accelerator, but that said my second gen has grown a lot on me. The body roll issue was never actually an issue. It was that the second gen actually handled bumps fairly better, feeling softer making me think the suspension as a whole is soft. But after some cornering, I was wrong. I do own the sport model with the select shift for both vehicles. I would however like to improve the response from the throttle if anyone has any ideas.
As for power, my second Gen easily thwarts the first Gen from a stock vs stock perspective.
Overall, the Second Gen is a much better car, a big step up. It is such a shame that Ford discontinued production after finally getting things right with this car.
I made a thread about parting my first gen. I am done with it, everything OEM that can fail - does. It's like I am rebuilding the car each year, and I have had enough. Only 280,000 kms on it. Such a disappointment.
And on that bomb shell, thank you everyone for the great comments here.